Bourbon is one of the most beloved spirits in the world, known for its smooth, rich flavor and deep complexity. Whether you are new to bourbon or a seasoned whiskey enthusiast, finding the right bottle can elevate your drinking experience.
At Pina Wine and Spirits, we have handpicked the top five bourbons that every whiskey lover must try. These selections include classic favorites, high-end sippers, and bold, full-bodied options, making them perfect for any occasion.
1) What Makes a Great Bourbon?
Before diving into our top five picks, it is important to understand what makes a bourbon truly great. Bourbon is a type of American whiskey that must meet the following legal requirements
- Made in the United States Most bourbons are crafted in Kentucky, but they can be made anywhere in the country.
- At least 51 percent corn The mash bill must contain at least 51 percent corn, giving bourbon its signature sweetness.
- Aged in new charred oak barrels Unlike other whiskeys, bourbon is aged in new, unused charred oak barrels, which contribute to its deep flavor.
- Distilled to no more than 160 proof Bourbon must be distilled at a lower proof than other whiskeys, ensuring it maintains its rich flavors and character.
Now that we understand what makes a great bourbon, here are the top five bourbons every whiskey lover must try.
2) Buffalo Trace – The Classic Must-Try Bourbon
Why You Should Try It
Buffalo Trace is one of the most consistent, well-balanced bourbons available today. It is produced at the famous Buffalo Trace Distillery in Kentucky, which has been crafting whiskey for over 200 years.
Tasting Notes
- Aroma Caramel, vanilla, and oak
- Flavor Smooth and rich with notes of toffee, cinnamon, and spice
- Finish Long and warm with hints of caramel and oak
Best Way to Enjoy
- Neat or on the rocks for sipping
- In an Old Fashioned or Whiskey Sour for cocktails
Buffalo Trace is an affordable and versatile bourbon, making it a great starting point for those exploring high-quality whiskey.
3) Woodford Reserve – A Smooth and Well-Balanced Bourbon
Why You Should Try It
Woodford Reserve is a premium, small-batch bourbon known for its complex flavor profile and smooth finish. It is a favorite among both new and experienced whiskey drinkers.
Tasting Notes
- Aroma Dried fruit, vanilla, and toasted oak
- Flavor Rich caramel, nutmeg, and dark chocolate
- Finish Long and smooth with a hint of spice
Best Way to Enjoy
- Neat or with a splash of water to open up the flavors
- Pairs well with dark chocolate and roasted nuts
Woodford Reserve is a perfect sipping bourbon that delivers a rich and complex experience with every glass.
4) Maker’s Mark 46 – A Rich and Full-Bodied Bourbon
Why You Should Try It
Maker’s Mark 46 takes the classic Maker’s Mark recipe and enhances it with additional oak aging, creating a bolder, richer bourbon. It is an excellent choice for those who enjoy full-bodied, flavorful whiskey.
Tasting Notes
- Aroma Toasted oak, caramel, and vanilla
- Flavor Bold and smooth with notes of baking spice, caramel, and honey
- Finish Deep and warm with lingering oak and spice
Best Way to Enjoy
- Neat or on the rocks for a smooth and rich experience
- Great in an Old Fashioned for an elevated cocktail
Maker’s Mark 46 is perfect for those who love a bold and complex bourbon that retains a smooth and easy-drinking character.
5) Elijah Craig Small Batch – Aged to Perfection
Why You Should Try It
Elijah Craig Small Batch is a well-aged bourbon that offers deep complexity and a rich mouthfeel. It is a favorite among whiskey enthusiasts and a great option for those who appreciate aged bourbons.
Tasting Notes
- Aroma Oak, caramel, and baking spices
- Flavor Deep vanilla, toasted nuts, and hints of smoke
- Finish Long, warm, and oaky
Best Way to Enjoy
- Neat or with a single large ice cube
- Pairs well with grilled meats and cigars
Elijah Craig Small Batch is an excellent bourbon for sipping, offering a mature and well-rounded drinking experience.
6) Blanton’s Single Barrel – The Ultimate Premium Bourbon
Why You Should Try It
Blanton’s is one of the most sought-after single barrel bourbons in the world. It is a premium whiskey that delivers a smooth, refined, and elegant drinking experience.
Tasting Notes
- Aroma Vanilla, honey, and citrus
- Flavor Rich caramel, spice, and oak
- Finish Long and smooth with hints of vanilla and toasted nuts
Best Way to Enjoy
- Neat for the ultimate sipping experience
- A great bourbon to collect or gift
Blanton’s is perfect for whiskey lovers looking for a premium bourbon, and its limited availability makes it a prized addition to any collection.
7) Final Thoughts Choosing the Best Bourbon for You
Each bourbon on this list offers something unique and special. Whether you are looking for a classic, well-balanced bourbon or a premium, high-end whiskey, there is something for every whiskey lover.
Recap of the Top 5 Bourbons Every Whiskey Lover Must Try
- Buffalo Trace – Classic and well-balanced
- Woodford Reserve – Smooth and complex
- Maker’s Mark 46 – Rich and full-bodied
- Elijah Craig Small Batch – Aged to perfection
- Blanton’s Single Barrel – Premium and collectible
If you are looking for the best selection of bourbon in Kansas City, visit Pina Wine and Spirits.
8) Find the Best Bourbons at Pina Wine and Spirits
At Pina Wine and Spirits, we carry a carefully curated selection of bourbons, from everyday favorites to rare and collectible bottles. Whether you are looking for a smooth sipper, a cocktail bourbon, or a premium whiskey for a special occasion, we have the perfect bottle for you.
Why Shop at Pina Wine and Spirits
- Wide selection of bourbons for all price ranges
- Competitive prices and exclusive discounts
- Knowledgeable staff to help you find the right whiskey
- Multiple store locations in Kansas City, Lees Summit, Liberty, and more
Stop by today and let our team help you find your new favorite bourbon.
Visit our website to check store locations and hours.
Enjoy the best bourbon experience with Pina Wine and Spirits.
